Friday, May 1, 2009

So Where Was Camp Willis?

I've learned that I should probably double check my sources before posting to the blog. I found that when I read through the directions under the "about us" tab on Lake James Christian Assembly website, there is a Google map, which shows that Lake James Christian Assembly is located on Crooked Lake (as I described in the previous post).

However, when I returned to the website, I read through the history section under the "about us" tab and found the following information: "Lake James Christian Assembly, located on the south end of the first basin of beautiful Lake James was a large resort area known as Palty-Town." That information accompanied by the following picture (found in the "contact us" section), which puts Lakes James Christian Assembly where it should be--on Lake James.



In the history, I also read that the dying resorts in Palty-Town had been bought and presumably renovated into the home of the Lake James Christian Assembly: "In 1928, the railroad had closed and activities were ceasing causing the sale of the resort. A group of men from the Angola Christian Church met and decided to buy the resort. One man obtained a personal loan of $800 for the down payment and twelve men signed a mortgage for $15,000."

This then raises the question, where was Camp Willis? If Lake James Christian Assembly is located where a resort used to be, Camp Willis was probably not in the same location. Of course, some people may have just assumed there was a connection between Lake James Christian Assembly and Camp Willis because they were both associated with youth acitivies for local Christian churches and with Lake James. I still cannot definitively say where Camp Willis was located, but I guess that it was indeed near the current Lakes James Christian Assembly and Palty-Town even if it had not been in the exact same location.

Monday, April 27, 2009

Locating Camp Willis

I had been trying to call Cynthia Pinkerton for a few weeks, but I could not get a response. When I called tonight, I was finally able to talk to her. I didn't get much information about Camp Willis or about her grandfather and founder of the camp, Edward D. Willis, from just talking with Cynthia, but she did say that she has more information and would pass it along to me via e-mail. Cynthia was undoubtedly the best person to contact regarding Camp Willis--she told me that her father had only one maiden sister, so all of the family's records have been passed down to Cynthia. If anyone knows anything about Camp Willis, it should be her.

Although I did not get much information from Cynthia, she was able to answer (to the best of her ability) one of the questions that I knew Jim and Flaim wanted answered: Where was Camp Willis? Cynthia told me that she had been told that Camp Willis was located in the first basin of Lake James, on the south end of the lake across from the state park. She told me that this spot eventually evolved in the Lake James Christian Assembly. The later (current) Christian summer camp was not related to Camp Willis, but they were supposedly located at the same spot.

I googled Lake James Christian Assembly and found a Google map that showed Lakes James Christian Assembly was located on Crooked Lake, just south of Lake James. Now I'm just confused. Why is Lake James Christian Assembly located on Crooked Lake? And if the Lake James Christian Assembly is located on Crooked Lake, was Camp Willis located there as well? Or was Camp Willis indeed located on Lake James?

Sunday, April 26, 2009

Fire on Lake James

I was surprised to see Lake James highlighted on the Saturday evening news and even more surprised to see that there had been a fire on the lake. WANE-TV reported that five homes had been destroyed causing $6 to 8 million in damage. I found the photo below on Wane.com


I wonder what, if anything, this fire meant for the Lake James History Project and for our class. Were any substantial pieces of Lake James history destroyed in the fire? Were the homes that burned down historic homes or McMansions? And even if they were McMansions, isn't that still considered some part of present lake life? Aside from the Lake James History Project, some people lost their homes or pieces of their own family or community history.

Seeing this story about Lake James on the news also made me wonder from whom or what are we trying to protect and preserve Lake James history. Are we trying to preserve history in spite of people's (conscious or unconscios) dismissal of the past and lack of effort to preserve it? Are we trying to protect history from natural destruction? In some cases, such as fire and natural disaster, we can only do so much to preserve history. That makes me wonder whom are we preserving this history for? Ourselves? Our children? Our grandchildren? How long do we expect our histories to last, and realistically, how long can they last?

Friday, April 17, 2009

Is ENG W397 Service Learning?

After our class discussion about whether or not the Writing Center Theory and Practice course (ENG W397) is a service learning course, I e-mailed Sara (that is, Dr. Webb-Sunderhaus) to get her input. She agreed that the Writing Center Theory and Practice course is not a service learning course because it is job-training. She went on to say that "Service to others--unpaid work--is not part of the course curriculum."

Sara did say that with a "generous interpretation," a person could argue that the Writing Center's clients benefit from the service, but still the consultants are paid for their work so it's not exactly service learning. She explained, "There just isn't the voluntary contribution to a community partner in 397." Of course, then a person could argue whether or not service learning is voluntary because it is typically required as part of the course curriculum. Either way, I don't think that ENG W397 could be considered a service learning course.

Sara also brought up something about service learning that we haven't talked about in much detail in class (although Suzanne has mentioned it, I believe): the work that is required for a professor or instructor in order to facilitate service learning in a course. Sara mentioned the following professor/instructor responsibilities: "do the planning, find a community partner, deal with liability issues, etc." I can understand why some professors or instructors might not want to have a service learning component in their courses; it take more time and effort than simply having students write papers and take tests.

Finally, Sara gave me a link to a service learning website with the following definition of service learning, which I thought we could add to our ever-expanding collection:

Service-learning combines service objectives with learning objectives with their intent that the activity will change both the recipient and the provider of the service. This is accomplished by combining service tasks with structured opportunities that link the task to self-reflection, self-discovery, and the acquisition and comprehension of values, skills, and knowledge content.

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Guilt and Lacking Motivation

I feel guilty knowing that I haven't done as much with the Lake James History Project as I should have by now. I'm going through the same thing I went through with my Family History Project: I can't make myself do something that could be done at some other time. When I have deadlines, I have to meet them. I have a quiz tomorrow, a critique due, and a draft of my business report, but I'm not required to have anything done regarding my part of the LJHP, so I probably won't do anything with it today.

Of course, that's not to say that I haven't done anything. I have found some information and gotten some contact information, but I just can't find time to make some of the phone calls that I need to make. I keep making excuses about how I can do it tomorrow or next week. Or maybe I should wait until the weekend so I can use the unlimited minutes on my cell phone. I seem to be making any excuse I can to put off doing what I need to do with this project, even if some of those excuse are legitimate.

I wanted to make a phone call this morning, but that didn't happen. However, I did lay in bed for about an hour this morning thinking about this project and feeling overwhelmingly guilty. The downfall of service learning is that when students procrastinate or don't do what they should be doing, they aren't just failing themsevles like they would in a traditional class. They are also failing those for whom they are supposed to be providing a service. I'm not doing my job as a student, but I'm also not doing my job as a researcher and writer for the LJHP. To remedy that, I plan to get some things done this week/weekend for the LJHP. I need to call the numbers that I have, and hopefully those individuals I call will have contact information for others who might have more information.

I feel guilty because I'm a slacker, but hopefully that guilt will make me start being more productive. Time is running out, and I really do want to make a worthwhile contribution to the LJHP and help Jim and Flaim with their research and writing. It's just difficult because when something can be done at any time, it never gets done, at least not until the deadline gets closer.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Unifying Theme for LJHP

Finding a common thread for all of the topics we have been given to research about Lake James will be kind of difficult considering this topics are so varied in time and place. What is the connection between Palty Town and the Indians (or Native Americans, to be politically correct)? What is the connection between Riley the surveyor and Camp Pokagon? There really isn't much connection between them at all besides the fact that they all relate to life around Lake James.

To connect these topics, we could use a common narrator like we talked about. This person could experience all of these things by visiting them, talking to other people, or finding artifacts around the lake. However, by doing that, we would be creating a very long and completely unrealistic narrator. Yes, most of those things could be experienced or talked about in a day, but to cover all of them in depth in a day by providing pictures, other artifacts, and short stories seems unreasonable. Regardless, I still think this would be a good way to connect all of our topics.

My other idea, although it may not make as cohesive a piece as if we used a narrator, would be to use a map of Lake James and highlight a part of the lake in each section/chapter. Instead of having a "person" narrator, we would just have an omniscient narrator who "travels" the whole lake by going to one spot at a time and giving its history. I thought we could use maps like this following map of Fort Wayne:


We could use a map of Lake James which highlights a particular place and an inlay of that place--the place we would be discussing in that section/chapter. This does make for a rather loose unifying theme, but it is true to the project because as far as I know, Lake James is the common thread for the Indians, trains, bands, Palty Town, camps, Riley the surveyor, and the family names that I don't know how to spell.

Finally, there's always the usual chronological approach: we could discuss happenings around the lake in the order they occurred. The only problem with this is that we would have the Indians and then a long stretch of time in which nothing really happened. Then, we would have Palty Town and other places around the lake coming into existence with everything happening in a much shorter amount of time.

We might come up with some new ideas for creating a unifying theme after talking with Jim and Flaim tonight, but as for right now, those are my ideas.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Wrapping Up My FHP

I did some work on my Family History Project over spring break, and I am happy to report that I have finished. I plan on reading over the finished product one more time tomorrow morning before turning it in, just to double check for some simple grammar or spelling errors, but besides that, I am done. And I must say, I am quite relieved.

I have enjoyed working on this project and learning more about my own family history and about genealogical research in general. However, I have been in a constant state of confusion and anxiety over this project for most of the semester--a sentiment that I made quite clear to Suzanne on more than one occasion. I spent the first few weeks of the semester trying to find a focus for my project, and then I spent the next few weeks trying to refocus so my project wouldn't be just a bunch of dry facts.

Although my project ended up consisting of a lot of "facts" just as I originally thought it would, I don't think it turned out as dry as I had planned. The finished project is not quite where I intended to go at the beginning of the semester, but I am happy with what I have managed to put together in just a few weeks.

Genealogy is an umbrella term for the endless hobby that deals with people, events, places, culture, food, clothes, dates, births, deaths, marriages, children, etc. And each of those things can be researched for my mother, my father, my mother's mother, my father's mother, my mother's mother's mother, my father's father's father...you get the idea. Through these past eight weeks, it has been hard focusing on one VERY small part of all of that and trying to make something of it, but I did it. And now, I'm done.